[quote name='CaptainJoel']I don't think I actually saw anything that I'd give a best of show to. If the question was, "What are you most looking forward to?" though, ME3 and Batman would be tied.[/QUOTE]
Best overall for me would be the Vita announcement.
If limited to games, I couldn't say anything stood as a "best overall", but like you, I can say I saw some awesome stuff. Like Uncharted 3, SFxT, SF3SO, Skyrim, ICO/SotC, GoW:Origins, Dragon's Crown, MGS HD Collection, SH HD Collection, ZOE HD Collection, etc.
I don't list Arkham City because I'm trying to stay "media blackout" on that and hope I'm as floored by it as I was by the first, which I'd written off as a stupid cash in game until I played it. I'm still looking forward to ME3, but I'm so burned out on ME at the moment that I can't even bring myself to finish my last playthrough of ME2... and the MS demo with kinect didn't really do it for me.