[quote name='arcane93']Picked up

Fallout 3 GOTY and

Hot Shots Golf. Didn't notice until I got home that Hot Shots Golf has a cut down the side of the case (through the cover), that was pretty obviously someone being careless with a packing knife. Grrrr. Oh well, it was only $5 -- not worth the effort to take it back.
Anyone know where the best trade-in deal is right now for a non-GOTY copy of

Fallout 3? Now that I've got the new one, there's no point in holding onto it anymore.[/QUOTE]
spun.com-$12.30(but they're really picky on condition)
estarland.com-$13(but they're also picky on condition I've heard)
I haven't really traded/dealt with either company, but those are the best two values I've seen. You may also want to consider Gamestop during their current 50% more(60% with EDGE) bonus trade-in credit deal.
The only problem with the other two is if they reject your game(s), I think you pay return shipping.
EDIT: Fallout 3 normal edition was getting $5.75(3/1/10) before 50% bump at Gamestop.