If the question had been 'what are the TWO best Futuristic Racing games?' Then WipeOut 3 would have been my second choice. I agree with everythig you said in your post, except that I wasnt as big a fan of the track design/layout in WO3. And whilee the Sasha soundtrack was awesome, I still like the various AstralWerks artists on XL better. And also since XL came first, I think the design and beauty of it had more of an impact on me. I expected WO3 to be great, but XL came out of left field, for me anyway. You really cant go wrong with either game, and both belong in anyones PS1 collection.
[quote name='donssword']Many WipeOut fans have fond memories of WipeOut XL -- it is a graphical tour-de-force, and its impact and style were unpassable for its time.
However, WipeOut 3 IMHO is a more thorough game, and I find it more appealing. WipeOut 3's strength's lie with its easier to use control scheme and support for dual sticks that was missing in WipeOut XL. And, WO3 still has the great music and visual stylings from Designer's Republic. WipeOut 3 has a huge number and variety tracks, unlockable ships, and 4 or 6 (I can't remember) levels of increasing difficulty.
WipeOut Fusion is a decent entry in the WipeOut series, but suffers without the touch of Designer's Republic -- this shows in its vehicle design and overall style. Fusion has an interesting vehicle upgrade system, it's well polished, it's PS2 environmental touches are beautiful, but it is missing that "something special" that was part of previous iterations. Still worth your money, especially if u have never played a WipeOut Game before.
WipeOut XL has an older control scheme and a steeper learning curve. WipeOut 3 introduced what is the current scheme in use.[/quote]