I don't think he was singling you out, I believe he was referring to the people that hate the direction the series took especially in 4, since that seems to be what I read around the net which coincides with 343 taking over the series.
I have never played Reach or ODST, but if they are better at story then maybe I should especially since I got one of them free with games with gold, as it stands I just don't see the hype behind the series. A lot of comments I see about peoples love for the series reference their first multiplayer experience over any of the story and lore so it's odd that now story and lore are now the selling points on the series but maybe it's momentum like someone said.
And don't think my opinions on Halo are because I'm a Sony guy, I was a 360 guy when Sony was attempting to destroy their brand with the PS3 launch, and I had zero interest in Halo 3. I also have never got past meeting Ellie in The last of Us and I've only played the 1st Uncharted. I just don't get wrapped up in liking games that everyone says I should.