[quote name='panzerfaust']People have a hard time explaining why Diablo II was fun and why Diablo III isn't, they make all the wrong arguments even though I'm starting to feel that at least they have the right position. It's like Crystalstalker crying about Diablo II and how it was "deep" when he has no clue why he even liked the game.
Diablo 3 right now feels like I'm part of this community that is merely in love with the idea of figuring out a broken game. The skill system destroys replay value, the loot was hardly worth picking up until half way into Hell difficulty, blacksmithing is still worthless, and the campaign, enemies, and ragdoll physics were all undeniably dump aspects of the game. But here we are laughing about the unbalanced brick wall that is Inferno, and I'm honestly having a good time figuring out this mess of a game out, too. But
what a mess this game is, you know? By any other name, I don't think such a game would be worth anyone's trouble.
But

it, D3 is here and we're gonna farm the hell out of it.[/QUOTE]
It's hard to hate a game I and my close friends have already invested so many hours into it. Are there things wrong with it compared to D2 and other games predating it? of course, but I can't seem to put it down.
With my friends, we each play a different way and not just class and gender. For one group, we play and take some sort of enjoyment in the struggle and journey. They asked if I explored everything cause that's how they roll...I said, "fog of war is a greater enemy than diablo." We don't use the AH, our drops are basically a pool of shared items giving it up out of necessicity. We even use gold on the blacksmith in hopes we can create something useful. A community...and there is much satisfaction when finally downing an near impossible champion pack in hell difficulty.
My other buds? They just want to speed through the previous acts, get achievemtns, and farm loot. They use the AH, they don't use the blacksmith, and in fact these friends while friends with my other friends don't play with each other.
So yeah...same reason why loot driven games are so addicting, this one just happens to have some serious cut scenes and while I may not be playing this for the next 2+ years, diablo 3 is like a part time job and I'm enjoying the crap outta it.
haters gonna hate, but you know they probably logged more hours than us and will continue to do so.