[quote name='Tha Xecutioner']Since I'm lumped into "Tali heads" :lol: I'll post a quick response:
For me, personally, it's not about some arbitrary level of dedication or fanboyism I have towards BioWare or the Mass Effect team in general - it's about optimism and past experiences with their games (KotOR, KotOR2, Jade Empire, etc.). I see the good in the videos/trailers they post, in the press conferences they have, and in the interviews they do on various sites. I think about how that not only deepens the game for someone like me (who'll have ~1000 hours of total Mass Effect time under his belt before the release of ME3), but also for people who didn't even play the first game. It's not that I'm pulling excuses/reasoning out of my ass to make "bad" things sound good in an effort to ignore the negatives or something - it's just that people don't always see the positives because of the often unfair focus that the negative aspects get.
I mention past experiences because I've never played a BioWare that I didn't absolutely love. The KotOR series was my favorite until Mass Effect came along, and Jade Empire and Dragon Age have seen a lot of hours. I have no reason to expect anything less than good from them, in terms of medium-large scale expansions, releases, DLC. Obviously, they don't bat one thousand - Cerberus Armor, for example - because no one does.
Also, what's to say that this DLC won't benefit the game/universe more? I'm sure I could splice together a 30-second video of pure Mako combat from ME1 and make it look exactly the same as the Hammerhead (minus the hovering and obvious weapon differences), but would that make it any less important to ME1 or the series?
There's just no way of knowing until you see or play the full DLC package for yourself. Even once you have played it - just because you don't get something out of it doesn't mean I won't. We all have different interpretations of the lore of the game, as made evident through discussions over the ending, the idea of who travels with Shepard to each mission, etc. People trying to claim their ideas as some sort of majority opinion really don't help either. It's been a steady stream of this type of community reaction since the announcement of the game:
Before ________ comes out: hatred, feeling of betrayal, disgust, anger
More information about ________ comes out: "well ________ could still be bad"
________ is released: things get relatively silent from the opposition, still small groups of people who hate ________[/QUOTE]
Thanks for explaining all that. Very nicely said. Mass Effect has been my baby that I've cuddled for a while and so any little ill effect towards that universe gets me uneasy and cautious. I'm not one of the folks that loved all the changes they made in Mass Effect 2, but still loved it for being Mass Effect yet it made me cautious on the direction EA is pushing it (yes I said EA). And I can tell (from watching the videos - they showed enough) that it just seems really unnecessary and out of the realm of Mass Effect. And it was hard understanding how folks could actually be impressed by it. But, I'll just wait and see how it plays out.
[quote name='Ink.So.Well.']And ME2 offers even less than that (exploration) and therein lies some of my problems with what I've seen thus far, but I agree both games are far from perfect. Unfortunately seeing as the shooter genre is more popular now than it has ever been (and the sequel obviously caters to its fan base) we aren't likely to see any serious balancing acts in ME3 for fear of Bioware alienating its new fans. Genre balance is still going to be skewed IMO. At the moment I can't imagine a happy medium being there but rather ME2.5: RPG Where Art Thou in the same vein as ME1: Shooter Where Art Thou?
Either way we'll see what the real deal is when the DLC is released. Now that I've seen it in action though it is relatively safe to say I'm expecting the worse.[/QUOTE]
Exactly. This is what gets me worried: Mass Effect 1 = 60% RPG 20% Shooter 20% Exploration. Mass Effect 2 = 70% Shooter %30 Role Playing. And then the big DLC pack is shown and adds 10 more percent to the shooter category. Which makes me scared shitless about what Mass Effect 3 is going to be, I seriously would not be surprised if it was Halo with a conversation wheel with the direction they are going.