[quote name='donburns99']Half.com has let me down quite a bit, at least on rarer titles like P1 and P2.
I personally wouldn't buy anything with the disc only, but if it has discs, manual and art in mint or better condition, the case doesn't matter much. Cases are easily replaceable with a brand new one for under $1.
I know a few people who won't consider a listing if the case has a crack in it.. that bugs me, but to each his/her own.
I also used to keep my eye out for listings that only sell the inserts/manuals (back when I was still hunting for PSX games besides EP). If you can find those in mint, it allows you to go for those disc only auctions, which normally end at a low price. Win-win when that happens.[/quote]
Most of the prices on Half.com can be pretty crappy, though you can find some gems. I picked up Grandia a few months back, completely mint, for $6 shipped. And I should've clarified that I have kind of the same outlook as you. I've gotten so used to saying case/manual when what I really mean is original cover art and manual.
I do wish somebody would open up a site for PS1 cover art/manuals to sell, so I could complete stuff. I use one site for PS2/GC manuals/cases, so I luckily have a lot of breathing room on those, but I'm a collector that actually plays the games I collect, which makes it rough on me to look for great condition games that can actually stand to be played.
And so I actually feel on topic: My copy should be waiting for me after my semester wraps up, and my Social Link pack should arrive a few days after. I kind of regret not getting that big art book now, but oh well.