Just finished the game today after 16 hours and I was very disappointed.
First I'll start with my minor gripes and then move to my major ones.
1. The switch to a platformer style needed a switch in control schemes as well. The game doesn't control half as well as something like New Super Mario or Mario 64. At least give me a run button.
2. The 3D portions are extremely limited and very boring aesthetically. Also, the timer is annoying (especially on 8-4). We should at least be able to upgrade the amount of time we spend in the 3D realm
3. The game is visually less impressive than Paper Mario 2 (with the exception of the space world). I am not a fan of the character designs for the NPCs in flipside, for instance. The enemies look good, though...mostly.
Now my major gripes:
1. The game is tedious. Seriously, why do I have to run like a hamster for extended periods of time or type the same word over and over. Or run across an empty screen for who knows how long...or spend forever going from flipside to
. Why do I have to fight through a tournament of incredibly easily dispatched foes? It was painfully obvious they were artificially trying to make the game longer. Also...why do I have to scroll through so much boring text...which brings me to...
2. The story is very boring. I paid attention the first half of the game, then I realized I just didn't care and skipped as much text as possible from then on. Sure, it is probably difficult to come up with an engaging story out of the Mushroom Kingdom, but seriously, is this the best they could do? I'd rather have had Bowser kidnap the princess. Luckily, there are some very humorous portions of the story, which makes me wish there were more of this and less of the "serious" stuff. Bowser was the only character I liked.
It's a really good game, sure, but it just wasn't anywhere near where my expectations were coming off of Paper Mario 2 and other recent Mario games.
I give it an 8.3/10