[quote name='craven_fiend']I'm going to have to disagree on a few things with you. I believe the Sox really need that heart of the order, #4 hitter. The player should be a lefty, to sandwich between Youk and Bay, or vice versa. In a perfect world, Martinez fills that spot, but I think he'll be in the 6 hole as the catcher, where he'll produce nicely.
SS is a glaring problem. Hopefully, Lowrie can atleast be a stop gap. I think the rotation at the top is set with Beckett and Lester. Wake is #4 if he is able to come back and cover 1B. If not, Clay is an alright 4.
I think Theo may go back to the rumored talks with the M's about Felix. As well as the Pads about Gonzalez. He's bound to make a splash if this team is on the outside looking in come post season.[/QUOTE]
They need a top 2 caliber starting pitcher. Not necessarily to supplant Lester, but because they're going to need two ace type pitchers and a Lester in order to compete with the Yankees. They're not Kansas City, they can afford it. They need another solid starter on top of that, I don't know if Matsuzaka, Buchholz, or Bowden give you that next year. They don't need another ridiculous Dan Duquette reclamation project in the rotation for 5 million dollars like Smoltz or Penny.
Sabathia, Burnett, Wang, Chamberlain, Hughes. Beckett, Lester, and... Maybe Wakefield? Who else can you really count on going into next year? Not Matsuzaka, not Buchholz. Wake's the perfect #5 and makes #5 money.
Right now the Sox don't have anybody I feel good about having hit 3 or 4. Youkilis and Bay are guys that are great #5 hitters but are guys you try to upgrade from if they're hitting 3rd or 4th. They could be the two best hitters on some NL West team, not the Boston Red Sox. They're nowhere near the caliber of Teixeira, Arod, or what Manny and Papi were. Most playoff teams have a better 3-4 combo than that.
Victor Martinez is a guy who ideally would hit down in the order, 6th or later on a good team. Thats outstanding for a catcher, but for a 1B/DH? Thats terrible. They need a lot more production and power out of the corner positions than that. Is a good hitting catcher two days a week worth being stuck with an offensively average at best 1st baseman or DH the rest of the time?