[quote name='n8rockerasu']That's not really a fair comparison because Shields is supposedly one of the top WW fighters in the world. A better comparison is Ryan Howard getting a single against Roy Halladay as opposed to hitting a home run. He's still successful. It's just not as flashy. GSP is swinging for contact...not for power.
The Hardy fight, I agree, he SHOULD have ended that one. But to do it, he would have literally had to break Hardy's arm. I really think it caught GSP by surprise that Hardy didn't tap, and then he just let him get out of it. That was a mistake, and it shouldn't have happened, but at the end of the day, GSP is a nice guy.
As for Kos, he couldn't see, but he was still dangerous. Remember that saying about wounded animals? For that matter, you could turn the tables and ask Shields why he didn't put GSP away when HE couldn't see. Neither of them was willing to put themselves out there enough to risk getting stopped. It was basically a fencing match. But Shields had far more to prove. If he wanted the belt, he should have put it all out there and taken it. He didn't.
Like Dana White said, he's fighting top competition. If he was demolishing all of them, you'd have to wonder if they were really that good. I mean, Randy Couture is a great example. He'll finish with a record of 19-11, which in itself doesn't look that impressive (as dumb ass James Toney pointed out). But when you look at the guys he fought and how many title fights he was involved in, it makes for a damn impressive resume. GSP is doing the same thing...but with a better record! He's facing top notch guys and doing whatever he needs to do to win. It's not flashy, but it's effective. Would I like to see him KO guys or make them tap? Of course. But it would bother me more if he tried that and ended up getting KO'd himself. For that matter, why is GSP the one deciding how the fight will go? If another fighter wants his belt, they need to step up and dictate the pace.[/QUOTE]
I agree with almost all of that.
GSP did not fight to his ability against kos. he wouldnt even throw combos, he literally just jabbed his face into a basketball. Kos was beat in the first round, I didnt think it was boring seeing a jab dominate that fight, I just thought there was a gaping opportunity for more.
The alves and fitch fights were good examples of GSP fighting to his ability in my opinion. He outstruck alves soundly, he beat the shit out of fitch standing. Both of those guys are as dangerous as kos is, alves more so imo, but GSP took it to both of them.
I have no issue with those fights going to decision because he went after them. Its when It looks like he is trying to play it as safe as possible and coast to the decision.
edit - with regards to the howard comparison, its not like him hitting grounders off halladay, halladay is a badass, theyre equals. GSP and kos or shields or hardy are not equals, he is significantly better than them.